Reviewers largely praise the episode for its high stakes and successful weaving of multiple plot threads into a cohesive climax.

: The character arc for Steve Harrington is frequently highlighted as a series high point, moving him from a stock "bully" to a heroic ally who helps fight off the Demogorgon .

: Many critics and fans on IMDb rate it as a standout, noting its ability to wrap up the central mystery of Will's disappearance while establishing a compelling sequel hook .