Andy is killed by an energy ball thrown by Rodriguez.
Every time Rodriguez fails to kill all three sisters, Tempus resets the day. Streghe 1x22
Realizing the imminent threat pointing directly at Prue, Andy steps in to protect the woman he loves. Andy is killed by an energy ball thrown by Rodriguez
With the loop finally shattered, the sisters successfully vanquish Rodriguez without ever knowing the mastermind Tempus was still pulling the strings from the shadows. Streghe 1x22